Wisdom of Crowds Podcast: Who Wrecked Afghanistan?

How did it all go wrong? Jennifer Brick Murtazashvili, a leading scholar of Afghanistan, joins Damir and Shadi to dissect the Taliban’s victory and discuss what it tells us about the failures of America’s nation-building effort. Why did the Afghan government collapse so quickly? Have the technocrats and NGOs in the democracy promotion industry been completely discredited? And for the sake of the Afghan people, should we now help the Taliban succeed in governing the country? Things get heated.

https://wisdomofcrowds.live/who-wrecked-afghanistan/

The Violent Logic of Humanitarianism

The U.S. occupation of Afghanistan sacrificed politics—the only viable route to peace—for massive corruption and violence, all committed in the name of humanitarian compassion.

“The idea that we’re able to deal with the rights of women around the world by military force is not rational.” This single sentence from President Biden’s ABC interview with George Stephanopoulos on August 18 exposed the paradox of humanitarian intervention. It acknowledged that trying to address violence with violence only serves to perpetuate it. 

https://bostonreview.net/war-security/faisal-devji-violent-logic-humanitarianism

The Arab Spring, Ten Years On

Islamists and autocrats have the run of things. But the millions who struggled for freedom should not be forgotten.

After a fleeting season of hope, despair has returned to nurture the pretensions of the ancien regime. “Realists” in distant lands have doubled down, proclaiming the resilience of Arab tyranny. In the American governing class, there is no longer any great sympathy with, let alone active encouragement for, liberal reform. The reactionary right has decided that America’s Enlightenment creed doesn’t apply to the Muslim Middle East; the progressive left is more critical of Middle Eastern tyrannies, with the glaring exceptions of Iran and the Palestinian territories, but has no interest in taking up a “freedom agenda” in Islamic lands. 

https://www.persuasion.community/p/the-arab-spring-ten-years-on

Would you recognize the Taliban?

The Taliban have returned to power in Afghanistan after two decades. Over the next few weeks and months, a host of foreign nations with a stake in the country’s future will have to make a very tough choice: grant legitimacy to a regime that has committed atrocities against its own people, or risk the potential fallout of turning Afghanistan into the isolated, drug-running state sponsor of terror it was prior to US occupation. For some, the decision will depend on how the Taliban behave, while others seem to have already made up their mind.

Here are a few arguments on both sides of the international recognition debate.

https://www.gzeromedia.com/would-you-recognize-the-taliban

The U.S. Government Lied For Two Decades About Afghanistan

*Read this piece and read again and then again then subscribe to Glenn Greenwald’s substack*

Using the same deceitful tactics they pioneered in Vietnam, U.S. political and military officials repeatedly misled the country about the prospects for success in Afghanistan.

None of this was true. It was always a lie, designed first to justify the U.S’s endless occupation of that country and, then, once the U.S. was poised to withdraw, to concoct a pleasing fairy tale about why the prior twenty years were not, at best, an utter waste. That these claims were false cannot be reasonably disputed as the world watches the Taliban take over all of Afghanistan as if the vaunted “Afghan national security forces” were china dolls using paper weapons. But how do we know that these statements made over the course of two decades were actual lies rather than just wildly wrong claims delivered with sincerity?

https://greenwald.substack.com/p/the-us-government-lied-for-two-decades?

Afghanistan: We Never Learn

As the Taliban waltzes into Kabul, the look of surprise on the faces of top officials should frighten us most of all

The pattern is always the same. We go to places we’re not welcome, tell the public a confounding political problem can be solved militarily, and lie about our motives in occupying the country to boot. Then we pick a local civilian political authority to back that inevitably proves to be corrupt and repressive, increasing local antagonism toward the American presence.

https://taibbi.substack.com/p/afghanistan-we-never-learn

Why We Failed: The American Exit From Afghanistan

Collection of brief, thoughtful essays reflecting on the end of US military involvement in Afghanistan

“Blame Our Incompetent Leaders. Especially Our Generals”

“Liberty Cannot Be Imposed Through Force”

“The White House Transforms Stalemate Into Catastrophe”

“The Stain of 2021”

“American Hubris and Mendacity”

https://bariweiss.substack.com/p/why-we-failed-the-american-exit-from?

News and Editorials about US withdrawal from Afghanistan

What We Got Wrong in Afghanistan

Military officers like me thought we were building a capable Afghan security force. What did we get wrong? Plenty.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/08/how-america-failed-afghanistan/619740/

Northern Afghanistan once kept out the Taliban. Why has it fallen so quickly this time?

Political and ethnic tensions have fueled new discord — and the Taliban has capitalized on these grievances

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/07/28/northern-afghanistan-once-kept-out-taliban-why-has-it-fallen-so-quickly-this-time/

Wisdom of Crowds Podcast: Afghanistan and the End of American Empire

With Kabul close to collapse, Shadi and Damir argue about the nature of the multiple screwups in Afghanistan, both long-term and of more recent vintage. What exactly is Biden doing wrong? Should we stay a bit longer, and if so, to what end? And what lessons should Americans learn from all if it?

https://wisdomofcrowds.live/afghanistan-and-americas-liberal-empire/

 

The Fall of Kabul

Joe Biden claimed “zero” parallels between U.S. withdrawals from Afghanistan and Vietnam. As the Taliban take Kabul, he’s proved wrong.

https://theintercept.com/2021/08/15/afghanistan-taliban-kabul-fall-saigon/

When ‘Never Again’ Becomes ‘Again and Again’

The U.S. has a responsibility to protect Afghans from the mass atrocities of the Taliban.

https://frenchpress.thedispatch.com/p/when-never-again-becomes-again-and

Our Best Stuff From a Frustrating Week

https://weekly.thedispatch.com/p/our-best-stuff-from-a-frustrating